Adirondack Chair Circle
"My aim is never to laugh at somebody." reads an interview with playwright Stephanie Alison Walker in the program to Steppenwolf Theatre's new world premiere, Adirondack Chair Circle. The play is not short on laughs, being a political satire in which a group of conservative Moms conspire against their liberal neighbors to remove books they consider "pornographic" from the school shelves. The performances are a joy, with Katrina Lenk, Sadieh Rifai, and Wendy Mateo as the self-righteous trio Banna, Libby, and Winona, Caroline Neff as their more tolerant neighbor Evelyn Grace, and David Darrow as an interfering crow, who gets under Banna's skin with physical comedy and tactical excrement, all directed with energy by Pam McKinnon.
The plot unfolds, mostly driven by the trio's scheming: Libby is removed from a school board meeting for assaulting a librarian. Libby tries to stuff a Little Free Library with porno mags to frame her neighbor. Libby organizes a protest march, with the help of the Proud Boys, to disrupt Evelyn Grace's pickleball tournament. The play's main characters, especially Libby, go to extreme lengths to get one over on their liberal neighbors and wrestle control of school policy. This is a major thesis of the play: that the motivation behind book bans is not one of care, but of control. Banna's relationship with her child most exemplifies this, as Banna claims to want the best for her family, but refuses to respect her child's changing gender identity.
It's a powerful, and largely accurate, portrayal. However, if one of the goals of the play is to examine the nuance where opposing ideas intersect, as the playwright interview suggests, I found myself wanting more. The only scene where the trio confronts their liberal neighbor directly ends with the conservatives being unable to define what "wokeness" is. Accurate as this is, I hoped for more shared examination of the women's feelings and fears about their children. There's a monologue in which Libby reads a salacious passage from one of the books in question, that seems primed to prompt the question, "Where IS the line of what should be allowed in schools?" The play doesn't much explore this question, instead implying that the book-banning mentality is entirely egotistical, a desire to "win", and is not at all related to genuine care for one's family.
Another of the play's stated goals is to encourage the (presumably mostly liberal) audience to laugh at themselves. However, the conservative characters are almost always the butt of the joke (so to speak), with the liberal Mom serving as the put-upon voice of reason. Evelyn Grace is a single Mom studying to become an immigration lawyer, who is well-behaved, civil, and doesn't get into any of the hijinks that so entertain us from the rest of the cast. Near the end of the play, she is physically victimized as an indirect result of her neighbors' actions, but still shows up to give a heartfelt speech to the school board. This play will no doubt make progressive audiences feel good about themselves, but there are some avenues of motivation and shared humanity that remain unexplored.
Adirondack Chair Circle is a hilarious and biting satire of the debate going on in countless real-world school districts. It's a play that will no doubt be picked up by companies across the company, and delight many audiences to come. Liberal ones, anyway. See it at Steppenwolf Theatre.

Comments